TL;DR
In a study of 57 healthy adults, Virginia Tech researchers found that nutritionally matched meals produced different metabolic responses depending on processing level. Brain scans also showed differences in reward-related responses to food images, though participants did not report being willing to pay more for either type of food.
Virginia Tech researchers found that ultraprocessed and minimally processed meals with closely matched calories and nutrients prompted different metabolic responses in healthy adults, alongside differences in reward-related brain activity. The study, published this month in Nature Metabolism, offers evidence that processing may affect responses to food beyond the meals’ measured amounts of carbohydrates, fat and protein.
Get oils, diffusers and self-care delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The study included 57 healthy adults aged 18 to 45. Researchers measured metabolism in all participants, while 32 also completed both the metabolic and brain-imaging sessions. Each participant ate both types of meal on separate visits at least three days apart, allowing researchers to compare responses within the same person.
Each test meal contained 300 calories and was matched within 1 percent for carbohydrates, fat, protein, water and salt. The ultraprocessed meal included portions of a peanut butter and jelly sandwich, deli turkey, vegetable chips, a cookie, cereal and instant mashed potatoes. The minimally processed meal included banana, dried cranberries, cheese and egg. Participants fasted overnight before eating; researchers collected blood samples after the meal and measured metabolism over three hours.
The researchers reported higher insulin responses after the ultraprocessed meal, with blood sugar remaining somewhat higher for longer. Participants also expended more energy and burned less carbohydrate for fuel after that meal, according to the study. In a separate session, participants viewed food images during functional MRI scans. Brain responses in the ventral striatum and nucleus accumbens—regions involved in motivation and reward—varied in relation to differences in carbohydrate burning. Participants did not say they would pay more for either category of food.
Processing May Shape Food Responses
The results add to research into why diets high in ultraprocessed foods have been associated with overconsumption and poorer health outcomes. The authors say their experiment suggests processing itself may be relevant to how the body handles a meal and how the brain responds to food cues, even when several basic nutritional measures are held nearly constant.
That distinction matters because ultraprocessed foods often differ from minimally processed foods in several ways at once, including sugar, fat, fiber and protein content. Matching those factors in a controlled comparison helps researchers investigate processing as a possible contributor, rather than assuming nutrient composition alone explains every difference. The study does not establish that processing causes obesity, diabetes, heart disease or mental-health conditions, nor does it show that a single meal produces lasting harm.
Ultraprocessed foods account for more than half of the average American’s daily calories, according to the source report, and their share of diets is rising in many parts of the world. The findings may help guide further research into how food formulation relates to eating behavior and metabolism. They do not, by themselves, provide a basis for judging an individual food or prescribing a particular diet.
Products Worth Considering

Oura Ring 4 Smart Ring, Silver, Size 10

Oura Ring 5 Smart Ring, Silver, Size 8

Bowflex SelectTech 840 Adjustable Kettlebell
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
A Controlled Meal Comparison
Nutrition research commonly focuses on the measurable composition of meals, including calories and macronutrients. The Virginia Tech team asked whether industrial processing might also matter when those factors are closely matched. The meals were classified using the Nova scale, which groups foods by degree of industrial processing.
Earlier population-level research has linked diets high in ultraprocessed foods with conditions including obesity, cardiovascular events and Type 2 diabetes. Such associations do not prove that processing is the cause: people’s diets and health are influenced by many factors, and highly processed foods often have nutritional profiles that differ from less processed alternatives. The new experiment examined immediate responses under controlled conditions, rather than tracking long-term disease.
For the metabolic sessions, participants ate after an overnight fast in a sealed room designed to measure energy expenditure. Researchers took measurements before and after the meal. The brain-imaging session took place on a separate day, when participants viewed pictures of foods and rated how much they would be willing to pay. This design connected short-term metabolic measures with responses to food cues, but did not test whether those responses changed what participants later ate.
“If you look at that population-level data, people who consume large amounts of ultraprocessed foods have higher rates of poor health outcomes — obesity, cardiac events, Type 2 diabetes, and even some metrics of mental health.”
— Alex DiFeliceantonio, associate professor at the Fralin Biomedical Research Institute at VTC
Long-Term Effects Remain Unknown
The experiment measured short-term responses to one 300-calorie meal, not the effects of eating these foods regularly over months or years. It cannot show whether the observed insulin, energy-use or brain-imaging differences lead to changes in appetite, food intake, weight or disease risk. The study also does not establish which features of processing might account for the differences.
The study involved a relatively small group of healthy adults, and only 32 completed both the metabolic and brain-imaging sessions. The source report does not provide enough detail here to assess how broadly the results apply to other age groups or people with existing health conditions. Participants’ willingness-to-pay ratings did not differ, and the reported brain findings do not establish that people found one type of food more rewarding in everyday life.
Further Studies Must Test Diets
The findings point researchers toward questions about which aspects of processing influence metabolic and brain responses, and whether those immediate differences persist with repeated exposure. Longer studies could test whether responses are reproduced across more participants, different foods and varied populations, and whether they relate to actual food choices or health outcomes.
The report does not announce a follow-up study or a planned clinical recommendation. For now, the published results are evidence of a difference under the specific conditions tested, rather than proof that all ultraprocessed foods produce the same response or that avoiding them will prevent disease.
Key Questions
What did the Virginia Tech study find?
Researchers reported that nutritionally matched meals produced different short-term metabolic responses. The ultraprocessed meal prompted a higher insulin response, greater energy expenditure and less carbohydrate burning than the minimally processed meal.
Were the meals matched nutritionally?
They were matched within 1 percent for calories, carbohydrates, fat, protein, water and salt. They contained different foods, and the study does not mean that all other characteristics were identical.
Did participants prefer ultraprocessed foods?
Participants viewed food images during brain scans and reported how much they would pay. The researchers found no reported difference in willingness to pay between the two categories, although some reward-related brain responses differed.
Does the study show ultraprocessed foods cause disease?
No. It measured responses over a few hours after a single meal. It does not establish that processing causes diabetes, heart disease, obesity or mental-health conditions, or show the long-term effects of a diet high in these foods.
Source: hn
