TL;DR
In the 117-patient STABLE trial, sustained breath holding during robotic bronchoscopy did not significantly improve diagnostic yield over conventional ventilation. Researchers said the findings may not apply to very small nodules, and the exploratory study needs further research.
A 117-patient randomized trial found that sustained breath holding did not significantly improve the diagnostic yield of biopsies taken during robotic bronchoscopy, compared with conventional ventilation. The results, presented at the CHEST annual meeting, suggest that stabilizing the lung with a breath hold alone may not make these procedures more successful, though the small exploratory study cannot settle the question for all lesion sizes or techniques.
Get oils, diffusers and self-care delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The STABLE trial randomized patients with peripheral pulmonary lesions to conventional ventilation or standardized end-inspiratory breath-hold ventilation during tissue sampling. Both groups underwent the procedure using the Noah Galaxy robotic bronchoscopy system, integrated augmented fluoroscopy and C-arm-based digital tomography, with tool-position correction.
By strict American Thoracic Society and American College of Chest Physicians criteria, diagnostic yield was 86.8% (46 of 53 patients) in the breath-hold group and 92.2% (59 of 64) with conventional ventilation. The difference was not statistically significant (P=0.338). Localization rates were also similar: 98.1% with breath holding and 95.3% with conventional ventilation (P=0.625).
Roshen Mathew, MD, of WVU Medicine Camden Clark Medical Center, who presented the results, reported that yield was higher when clinicians confirmed the instrument was inside the lesion: 95.9% with tool-in-lesion confirmation, compared with 85.0% when the tool was classified as touching the lesion. Breath holding did not significantly improve tool-in-lesion positioning. The reported pneumothorax rate was about 1.7%, and radiation exposure was comparable between groups, averaging 5.8 minutes and about 38.6 mGy.
Target Alignment May Matter More
The findings matter because robotic bronchoscopy is used to reach and sample lung lesions that can be difficult to access, and biopsy results can guide decisions about further testing or care. The trial did not show a significant diagnostic-yield benefit from adding sustained breath holding to the procedure used in this study. It does not establish that breath holding has no value in other settings, but it weakens the case for assuming that holding the lung still will, by itself, improve sampling results.
Mathew emphasized the role of dynamic imaging and checking the instrument’s position relative to the target. The study’s higher yield when the tool was confirmed inside a lesion is an observed comparison, not proof that this factor alone caused the difference. Still, it points to a practical question for clinicians: whether real-time reassessment and correcting tool alignment during sampling are more useful than relying on a static position or breath hold alone.
Products Worth Considering

Garmin Forerunner 265S Running Smartwatch, 42 mm, Whitestone/Neo Tropic

Hyperice Hypervolt Go 3 Percussion Massage Gun with Carry Case

Oura Ring 4 Smart Ring, Silver, Size 10
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How the STABLE Trial Worked
The study compared two ventilation approaches during biopsy: conventional ventilation and a standardized end-inspiratory breath hold intended to stabilize the target lesion while tissue was collected. All cases used the same robotic platform and imaging approach, so the reported comparison concerns these methods within that procedural setup, rather than every form of bronchoscopy or breath-hold technique.
The average lesion measured about 1.7 centimeters. Mathew cautioned that relatively few nodules measuring 5 or 6 millimeters were included, limiting conclusions about very small targets. The trial was described as a small exploratory analysis, and its results were presented at a medical meeting.
“Breath hold after you have achieved integrated imaging with your robot really doesn’t improve diagnostic yield.”
— Roshen Mathew, MD, presenting the STABLE trial results
Limits for Smaller Lung Nodules
The findings do not establish whether a longer breath hold, apnea ventilation or a different ventilation protocol would produce another result. Kwan, who was not involved in the trial, asked whether the breath hold had been long enough and whether apnea ventilation might have improved yield. Mathew said the biopsy took five to seven minutes, but the length of the breath hold within that period was not measured.
The study also included few nodules as small as 5 or 6 millimeters, and its mean lesion size was about 1.7 centimeters. It is not clear whether the results apply to the smallest lesions, other robotic systems, or procedures using different imaging and sampling methods. The trial was small and exploratory, so the results should not be read as proof that breath holding can never help.
Further Testing Is Needed
Mathew said further study is needed. The reported results do not provide a timeline for another trial or specify what protocol researchers will test next. Future research would need to clarify whether breath-hold duration or apnea ventilation changes outcomes and whether the findings differ for very small lesions.
For now, the study reports no significant yield advantage for sustained breath holding under the tested conditions. Clinicians and researchers will need additional evidence to determine whether that result holds across patients, lesion sizes and procedural approaches.
Key Questions
Did breath holding improve lung biopsy diagnostic yield?
Not significantly in the STABLE trial. Diagnostic yield was 86.8% with breath holding and 92.2% with conventional ventilation; the reported difference was not statistically significant (P=0.338).
How many patients were included?
The randomized trial included 117 patients with peripheral pulmonary lesions: 53 in the breath-hold group and 64 in the conventional-ventilation group.
What did the researchers say may matter during sampling?
Presenter Roshen Mathew emphasized dynamic imaging and checking the tool’s alignment with the lesion. The trial reported a 95.9% yield with tool-in-lesion confirmation and 85.0% with tool-touch-lesion, but that comparison does not by itself prove that alignment caused the difference.
Do the findings apply to very small nodules?
That is unclear. The study included relatively few 5- or 6-millimeter nodules, and the mean lesion size was about 1.7 centimeters. Mathew cautioned that the results may not generalize to the smallest lesions.
Could a different breath-hold method change the result?
The study does not answer that. During discussion, session moderator Hoi Yee Kwan asked whether a longer breath hold or apnea ventilation might affect yield. Breath-hold duration was not measured, and further research is needed.
Source: rss
